C-212 · Strongly supported

The 1920 declarant Sam Silverstein is strongly supported as the Sam of the East 8th Street draft/census cluster and 1926 petition.

Evidence

Exact birthday, address, trade and name combine with Sara in the naturalization reports. Petition 90508 agrees on declaration date and Southern District court. The comparison does not require normalizing the draft’s town; dependent petition readings are not additional sources.

People
Samuel W. Silverstein
Places
—
Family lines
—
Supporting sources
Sam Silverstein: 1920 declaration and discrepant voyage report, Sam Silberstein: WWI draft report and East 8th Street identity comparison, 1925 New York census: Silverstein household and East 8th Street address, Sam Silverstein petition for naturalization, no. 90508
Contrary sources
—

What remains uncertain

The petition’s inspected Fifth clause does not show 87045, so exact numbered legal attachment is unproved. Repeated declarant accounts are dependent birth/arrival testimony. Pike identity, the earlier unnamed wife, continuous residence, Sara/Sal, biological relationships and all vital/voyage conflicts remain unresolved.