Sam Silberstein: WWI draft report and East 8th Street identity comparison
- Repository
- National Archives; reproduced by Ancestry
- Reference
- U.S. World War I Draft Registration Cards, 1917–1918, collection 6482, record 11755826, image 005263041_00907; New York, Manhattan City, board 104. NARA M1509 collection attribution; exact roll not independently established.
- Date
- Undated registration face; co-displayed report June [1 or 7?] 1918
- People
- —
- Places
- —
Reliability and limits
The registration face reports Sam Silberstein, age 29, birthday 15 July 1887, presser, alien and married, with a wife and three unnamed children as dependents. Its exact East 8th Street address, withheld here, matches the studied Sam’s later census and petition cluster. Name, address, trade and birthday strongly support C-207 without requiring a town-name match. The birthplace lettering remains unresolved; Shedlitz is a context-informed possibility, not independent confirmation. The report day is June 1 or 7, 1918, not an unqualified 7. A July 1887 birth gives age 30 then, not the face’s 29. The image co-displays face and report but no repeated registrant name independently proves physical pairing. No swapped reverse, copying explanation or actual 1917 registration date is established. Unnamed dependents establish neither specific children nor biology or residence. No continuous residence, legal name change, person alias, parent or brother identification follows. The Pike candidate remains unresolved; the separate 1942 candidate and 1887/1891 discrepancy are unchanged. Provider access may require an account or membership. Metadata and independently worded factual summary only; no source image, full transcript, signature or unrelated-person details are reproduced.
Supported discoveries
Confirmed concerns the literal name, address, occupation, birthday and dependency report. The exact street number is withheld.
The exact address, presser occupation, 15 July 1887 birthday and name form identify a specific cluster without relying on uncertain town lettering. Dependent readings and indexes are not extra historical witnesses.
Publication boundary
This page publishes citation metadata only. A public citation does not make the original scan, transcription, translation, or restricted file public.