Sam Silverstein: 1920 declaration and discrepant voyage report
- Repository
- National Archives at Philadelphia; reproduced by Ancestry
- Reference
- Declaration of intention 87045, printed page 461; RG 21, NAI 4713410; provider roll 173, declarations 86585–87084, box 090. Collection 2280, record 6399447. Repository/reel details are provider metadata, not a separately inspected reel.
- Date
- May 14, 1920
- People
- Samuel W. Silverstein
- Places
- —
Reliability and limits
The declaration reports Sam Silverstein, age 32, presser, birthday 15 July 1887, birthplace Shedletz, Russia (town spelling moderately confident), and wife Sara, Russia-born and residing with him. Its exact East 8th Street address, withheld here, matches the draft/census/petition cluster. The oath year combines printed 191 with handwritten 20, interpreted as 1920. It reports travel from Antwerp aboard Vaterland and arrival in New York on 22 March 1914. These are literal reports, not established birth or voyage events. The later certificate and petition reports give 1 April 1914 and Vaderland; the certificate names Zilberstein, Leiser without a numbered manifest row. The manifest reports Antwerp departure 21 March and New York arrival 1 April, so 22 March is not literally that departure either. No correction, distinct actual voyage, sailing-date explanation or fraud allegation is adopted. The teenage/single manifest versus 1887 birth/1908 marriage discrepancy remains unresolved. Petition 90508’s Fifth clause agrees on declaration date 14 May 1920 and Southern District court but does not show 87045; exact numbered legal attachment is unproved. Repeated applicant reports are not independent birth/arrival testimony. The named wife does not identify the earlier draft’s unnamed dependents or establish Sara/Sal equivalence or biological maternity. Pike identity remains unresolved. Provider access may require an account or membership. Metadata and independently worded factual summary only; no source image, full transcript, signature or unrelated-person details are reproduced.
Supported discoveries
Confirmed applies to the source report, not to adoption of the reported birth or journey as established events. The exact address is withheld.
Exact birthday, address, trade and name combine with Sara in the naturalization reports. Petition 90508 agrees on declaration date and Southern District court. The comparison does not require normalizing the draft’s town; dependent petition readings are not additional sources.
Publication boundary
This page publishes citation metadata only. A public citation does not make the original scan, transcription, translation, or restricted file public.