Sam Silverstein draft-card candidate: conflicting birth year and unlabelled contact
- Repository
- National Archives at St. Louis, reproduced by Ancestry
- Reference
- New York fourth-registration draft cards, Record Group 147, box/roll 562, name range Sikes, Sherman–Simmons, Carlton; Ancestry collection 1002, record 17024577, images 44544_08_00044-01394 and 44544_08_00044-01395. Repository and reel details are provider citation.
- Date
- Front undated; adjoining unnamed reverse reports 1942-04-27, conditionally associated
- People
- —
- Places
- —
Reliability and limits
The card front names Sam Silverstein, reports birth on 15 July 1891 and age 50, and gives Hasbrouck, New York, with Sarah Silverstein as the named contact. It does not state Sarah’s relationship. A provider category such as Next of Kin is not an original kinship statement. The birth town is read only as S[?]dlitz, possibly Sedlitz; Russia is the written country, without a modern-place substitution. The middle-name answer None does not authorize changing another record’s name. The adjacent unnamed reverse reports 27 April 1942 and Local Board 310. Its association rests on recorded viewer adjacency and compatible form/county, not an independently named reverse or a shared identifying number; its date and board are conditional on that pairing. Age/date consistency is internal to one candidate registration, not independent corroboration. The original’s 1891 conflicts with the existing 1887 birth report. The card remains a candidate for comparison, not an accepted identity with the Samuel in other family records. It does not prove that Sarah is a wife, Sam is a father, a move occurred, or a particular parent or brother existed. A card without a sibling field cannot disprove a recalled brother. Indexes, two faces and modern readers are not separate historical witnesses. Metadata and an independently worded factual summary only; no images, transcript, signatures, telephone or card numbers, medical or physical-description fields are reproduced. Provider access may require an account or membership.
Supported discoveries
Confirmed/high is limited to the clear literal card-front report. Independent image-only reading agrees on those fields, including 1891. This does not establish identity with the Samuel in other family records.
Publication boundary
This page publishes citation metadata only. A public citation does not make the original scan, transcription, translation, or restricted file public.