C-222 · Strongly supported

Fanny, Flora, Joseph, James and Walter in the 1900 and 1910 censuses represent continuity of the same five-person Brandenstein–Rosenberg family cluster.

Evidence

Five recurring named persons, coherent role changes, birthplace patterns, children’s ages, Fanny’s four children/two living and marriage-duration progression provide multiple discriminators. James February 1894/6 becomes 16 and Walter July 1898/1 becomes 11 at the exact reference dates. This assertion excludes resolving the 1900 head name or identifying Linda as Louise.

People
—
Places
—
Family lines
—
Supporting sources
1900 San Francisco census: Brandenstein household and Rosenberg cluster, 1910 San Francisco census: Brandenstein household and Rosenberg cluster
Contrary sources
—

What remains uncertain

At the population reference dates 1 June 1880, 1 June 1900 and 15 April 1910: Fanny’s 1880 age 34 conflicts by two years with May 1844 (expected 36); Myer’s qualified 1880 age 46 differs by one year from May 1833 (expected 47). Fanny’s 1900 age 56 and 1910 age 65 are compatible with the May birthday and different reference dates. Joseph’s September 1861 implies 48 in April 1910, not recorded 47. Fanny’s immigration 1865 in 1900 versus 1863 in 1910 conflicts. Flora’s 1900 December 1877/1879 remains unresolved; age 20 is preferred, 22 retained as alternative. Louise in 1910 is not silently Linda. The 1880 address remains 7[0/2]9 O’Farrell. A related namesake household or inaccurate informant reports remain possible; census creation is separate but underlying family knowledge may be shared.