Harold Louis Schafer of the 1940 adult records is strongly supported as Harold L., age 4, listed as Frank L. Schafer’s son in the 1910 Lincoln Township household with wife Cecil E. The 1974 certificate reports Harold Lewis Schafer with the same reported 7 November 1905 birthday, spouse Alice L. Wilkinson, father Frank Lewis Schafer and mother’s maiden name Cecil Miller.
Evidence
The 1974 certificate supplies a distinguishing adult parent-bearing bridge: the exact reported birthday, named spouse and explicit Frank Lewis Schafer/Cecil Miller pair. The 1940 census and draft correlate through adult name, age, Nebraska birth, Fort Calhoun/Washington County locality and Ford connection; the census names Alice, while the draft does not personally name her. The 1925 index separately pairs Harold L. and Alice L. Wilkinson. The 1910 Harold L., age 4, Nebraska-born son of Frank L., fits the reported birthday and parent-name combination. This compound match materially outweighs a same-name-only alternative, while the status remains strongly_supported/high rather than confirmed identity or biology. Derivative tree and notice compilations are not necessary to this assessment. Known counterevidence is included: the correlated 1930 household reports Harold’s father born Nebraska and mother Kansas, versus Michigan and Iowa in 1910. Both state conflicts remain explicit. They do not give a different named parent pair and do not outweigh the exact birthday, spouse and named-parent bridge, but neither report is assumed true or assigned a preferred error mechanism. Distinct documents can share family knowledge, and indexes, crops, packaged pages and modern readers are not additional historical witnesses.
- People
- —
- Places
- —
- Family lines
- —
- Supporting sources
- 1910 Lincoln Township census: Harold L. with Frank L. and Cecil E. Schafer, 1940 Fort Calhoun Township census: selected Harold and Alice Schaffer entries, Harold Louis Schafer: 1940 draft registration and contextually paired reverse, Harold L Schafer and Alice L Wilkinson: paired 1925 Nebraska marriage-index entries, Harold Lewis Schafer: selected 1974 Missouri death-certificate spouse and parent fields
- Contrary sources
- 1930 Omaha census: selected Harold and Alice entries and conflicting parental birthplaces
What remains uncertain
Louis/Lewis remains source-specific. Frank Lewis is not automatically Frank Lloyd; Cecil Miller/Cecil E. does not expand to Cecil Ellen. Identifying the 1910 wife with the certificate’s reported mother is cross-record inference; wife and son labels alone do not prove biological maternity. The death certificate’s birth/parent details are late information. No exhaustive namesake exclusion, exact parental dates, Alice parents or exact wedding day is established. The 1930 adult initials, possible surname ending and overwritten age remain qualified; Alice’s age is 23/24. First-marriage ages 21/20 are not a wedding date or proof that the first marriages were to each other. Harold’s reported November 1905 birth makes him 19 or 20 in 1925, not 21. These tensions are retained rather than normalized.